Bev Johns: Senate Bill 1 is the New Senate Bill 16. Senator Manar is still at it.

Beverley Holden Johns

Bev Johns and me at a 2014 Special Education meeting.

– By Beverley Holden Johns. Bev is a special education advocate and activist and her analysis frequently appears on this site.

Overall, SB 1 proposes NO new money, just a shifting of current money. SB 1 would change all of school funding in Illinois by taking away dedicated funding for special education teachers and other professional personnel.

SB 1 does NOT change the maximum amount of General State Aid (GSA) money that has been in Illinois law since the 2009-2012 school year: $6,119 per pupil. SB 1 would take away special education money and use PART of that money for a block grant and PART of special education money to shift funding from one school district to another.

The one change for special education in SB 1 from SB 16 is that the assumed number of special education students, 13.8 percent, can be increased if a district has up to 18.8 percent of students with disabilities. The weighting factor for the special education block grant remains at a much too low 1.0, and the future base percentage for the block grant remains a guess provided by ISBE as to the number of students with disabilities in public schools (rather than the number of students with IEPs).

Senate Bill 1 is largely an attempt to cover over a failure to fund Illinois schools by taking away direct funding of special education teachers and re-distributing that money in a block grant. The GSA formulas worked very well when Illinois was properly funding schools and still partly work today.
Special education Personnel Reimbursement, which is separate from GSA, now provides $9,000 for each special education teacher, each school social worker, each school psychologist, each school nurse and other professionals that work full-time with special education students.

SB 1 would completely abolish this dedicated funding for special education Personnel Reimbursement, which now provides up to 1/3 of a special education teacher’s salary in a poor district, but less than 1/10 of that salary for some teachers in a wealthy district.
This school year under GSA, the 64 highest wealth school districts are entitled to receive only $218 per student, while the 86 poorest school districts are entitled to receive over $4,000 per student. This school year, Illinois is funding only 89 percent of those GSA amounts (proration). In other words, the poorest school districts are losing over 6 percent of their total budgets, while the wealthy school districts are losing about 1 percent of their total budgets.

More importantly, Illinois has failed for years to provide the needed funding increases for K to 12 education. In 2002, by State law, Illinois was to provide $4,560 per student through a combination of State and local funds (which was determined based on low-spending but high achieving school districts). Now, by State law, Illinois is to provide only $6,119, although the amount determined based on low-spending but high achieving school districts is $8,672.

As Jim Broadway, Illinois School News Service, stated on January 6, ‘The formula no longer works’ because ‘the original formula was crafted to work satisfactorily as long as the state’s share of total PK-12 public school funding would be 50% or so, with the local share maybe 40% to 42% and the feds paying the rest. As the state’s share has fallen from a peak of about 48.5% in the mid-1970s to less than 30% of the total today, the portion paid by local property owners has ballooned to 60% or more.’

You cannot cover over the failure of Illinois to fund schools by blaming formulas that work as intended when schools get the funds they need.

5 thoughts on “Bev Johns: Senate Bill 1 is the New Senate Bill 16. Senator Manar is still at it.

    1. No. Your math is wrong and don’t confuse the state funding formula with school funding. Because the state spends so little on education and funds its schools primarily by local property taxes, the gap between poor school districts and wealthy ones is enormous.

  1. I went to the World Almanac and they have the state by state figures. Illinois overall is not horrible-if we had paid the pensions we might be one of the best – but its funding source is a joke …57% local -Property Tax BUT our federal is a freaking joke 10% Manar did offer a few more dollars and offer to take it from Medicaid …..Normally I don’t like it but we are getting screwed by the feds and maybe its time to ask why Texas gets a better deal than we do -a much better deal….The SCOTUS gave us a lot of leverage and we have nothing out of an Illinois President.

  2. Anony, the real intent of this bill is NOT to “equalize” education funding. I know of a school district that was promised (?–a political promise?!) $24 million in new revenue–& we all know that’s not gonna happen, regardless, because–doncha’ know?–“Illinois is BROKE!”–Civic Committee, Ty Fahner. The REAL state equalizer referendum was given to ILL-Annoy citizens as many years ago as Jonathan Kozol’s tragic book, Savage Inequalities, was published, & I was one who did vote yes (&–who knows? May have been the same situation then–ALEC was well into its evil plans). Anyway, this time, it’s all a ploy from Robin Steans’ group, Advance ILL-Annoy, which “explains”–w/their–“can’t-dazzle-em–w/their-brilliance-so-baffle-us-with-their-B.S.” colorful power point presentations “explaining” just HOW MUCH all “these” children will benefit . No, what this is going to do is take so much money away from the other school districts that those, too, will have to cut staff, programs and, generally, deconstruct everything that their schools have. Now–why?
    Hmmm…since CPS couldn’t keep using the excuse of “failing” schools vis-a-vis poor test scores (on those piss-poor, faulty Pear$on tests), because the public got wise to that, CPS stealthily embarked on the slow cash-starvation of its schools–you know, that’s why there’s one social worker to almost 1,000 students, no school libraries, art-on-a-cart (if even that), etc. Then, when the schools fare poorly due to lack of funds, they are…closed, to be replaced with–charter schools!!! And THAT’s what this whole Advance ILL-Annoy (which has bought legislators, in the ALEC tradition–check your local reps./sens. campaign contributions) agenda is (Sen. Heather Steans–Robin’s sister–you know, founder/supporter of the ILL-Annoy State Charter Commission; Steans Family–Dad a wealthy Lake Forest financier, banker, investment corp. owner, etc., ad nauseum).
    So, as it were, the plot thickens. BTW, an excellent article on this can be found in the Glenview Journal (sorry–poor w/links–but you can Google it–Glenview Journal, Maureen Pekosh, title is something like, “Don’t be Fooled…” & explains how both the elementary & HS
    districts in Glenview would lose OVER $5 million dollars.
    Lots of lost programs, faculty…and ripe pickin’s for, well, Concept?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s