Who fights for us?


Screen Shot 2016-04-12 at 4.09.58 PM

I received a phone call from Jeri Shanahan today.

“Sorry if I am pestering you,” Ms Shanahan said.

“Not at all, Ms Shanahan.”

Ms Shanahan is a retired Illinois teacher who is not Medicare eligible. According to the law she doesn’t qualify for Medicare because she retired too many years ago.

If she moved to Arizona or Florida she would pay half of what she pays for health insurance. She chooses to remain in Illinois, so she gets socked.

A bill was introduced in the Illinois legislature to address this situation that impacts maybe 500 retired very elderly teachers.

Ms Shanahan told me the bill failed. It had either the opposition or no support by the IFT and the IEA. Ms Shanahan wasn’t sure and I couldn’t find out.

I wasn’t shocked to hear that. Some days I feel like the state teacher unions aren’t just not for us. They are against us.

Us being retired teachers.

Glen Brown posted about this issue a number of times back 2013.




When Glen wrote about it in 2013 there were about 600 teachers impacted.

Retirees, 65 and older and not eligible for Social Security and Medicare, will pay the highest premium for Teachers’ Choice Health Plan in 2014: $719.96 (Illinois Department of Central Management Services. They are also paying more than twice as much as retirees not eligible for Social Security and Medicare but living out-of-state.

Now the number is 500. It is not 100 less because the problem is being solved, if you get my drift.

The state is just waiting them out.

Last year when Glen and I were Retired delegates to the IEA Representative Assembly, he brought the issue up.

“She should get a job and get her 40 quarters,” one IEA Retired leader told us, referring to Jeri Shanahan.

That right there is some cold stuff.

Shortly after the RA we got a message back from IEA lobbyist Will Lovett. It read, in part:

Our larger fear during the current legislative session is the fiscal health of the TRIP program. The Governor has proposed eliminating the state contribution to TRIP entirely.  We have had conversations about this concern dating back to 2011.   As you are aware, TRIP is funded by premiums paid by retirees, contributions by school districts, contributions by active members, and the state in turn matches the active teacher contribution.  The Governor’s proposed budget would eliminate between $95-$100 million in state funding for TRIP.  The program is roughly a $500 million program.  We wish that we could talk about a benefit enhancement or premium reduction for participants but protecting the program as it currently exists is our main priority in this current budgetary environment. 

Fairness for 500 retired teachers? The IEA has bigger fish to fry. She and the other 500 retirees are just not a priority in the current environment.

This weekend the IEA Representative Assembly is meeting again. Neither Glen nor I will be there. I’m not with the IEA anymore. And I think Glen has lifetime membership, which means he will be counted on the membership rolls long after his last TRS check. Will anybody speak for Jeri Shanahan and the other 500 retired teachers who are getting ripped off?

Not likely.

Here is Jeri Shanahan’s testimony before the Commission on Government Forecasting & Accountability.

9 Replies to “Who fights for us?”

  1. Another great example of our stalwart Union leaders helping those who really need it. Maybe I.R.T.A. can help her. At least they will try.

  2. Outrageous response from the IEA Retired “leader” (“leader” of whom? The people who would have retirees simply die & be rendered “soylent green” to be fed to the masses?!). And where would Ms.Shanahan be offered this “job”–at Walmart, as a greeter? (&, correct me if I’m wrong, but, as Walmart’s profits have decreased {but not the Walton family’s wealth}, numerous Walmarts have been closed, causing. of course, a multitude of unemployment.) Sadly enough, though, the IEA/NEA doesn’t really even well represent active teachers–supporting common core, not speaking against “standardized” testing or loudly enough against school privatization, working with Arne Duncan, the gaffes of the IL gubernatorial race (backing & giving money to the former ILL-Annoy Chairman of ALEC, rather than backing someone to primary the union back-stabbing Quinn!}&, latest & certainly not least, going along w/the early NEA endorsement of HRC, while the NEA asked for NOTHING in return for the endorsement, & the first debate had not even been held. (Power concedes nothing w/o demand.–F. Douglass)
    And all that is why I will not be renewing my IEA/NEA membership this fall.
    I don’t need no stinkin’ benefits! (i.e., Hertz, restaurant, hotel, etc. discounts)
    We can all get the same from AARP, IRTA & Triple A.

    P.S.–This is not a slam on the locals. I always had great support from my local, & most teachers I know did, as well. (& I was a Bldg. Rep. almost every year I taught, as well as a Recording Sec’y. & a Strike Coordinator {strike lasted only a week, very successful & LOTS of parent/community support}.)

  3. Sure!!! Go out and earn your 40 quarters to get a break on Medicare. THEN, watch the government withhold (steal) a big chunk of her earned Soc Security as penalty for having her TRS pension.

  4. I think IRTA may want to look at legal options. Were teachers promised a health benefit? If they have then it’s time to go to court because….we have an ILSC ruling called Kanerva.

  5. This is wrong, to be sure. I recommend that Ms. Shanahan try to get on Medicaid, (Making less than 18K per year) or simply make small payments on her health care bills until she no longer needs the care. You can’t get blood (money) out of a (deceased) turnip! Her heirs cannot be held responsible for her bills.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s