May 8th is Illinois Constitution Day.

Screen Shot 2017-05-15 at 7.50.36 AM
New IEA officers  were elected at last month’s Representative Assembly. From left, vice president, Al Llorens, president Kathi Griffin, secretary-treasurer Tom Tully. Will they reject the past practice of supporting pension theft in exchange for a seat at the table?

May 8th went by with little fanfare.

Anne and I walked up to a neighborhood wine bar to toast the event.

Today a few fellow retirees will have lunch together and share stories of how May 8th became our unofficial Illinois Constitution Day.

When the Democrats led by Governor Pat Quinn and Speaker of the Illinois House voted to steal the pensions of Illinois’s public employees in December of 2013, they violated the language of the pension protection clause of the state constitution as well as their obligation to the rights of the citizens of the state of Illinois

On May 8th two years later the eight members of the Court said so.

“The General Assembly may find itself in crisis, but it is a crisis which other public pension systems managed to avoid and … it is a crisis for which the General Assembly itself is largely responsible,” Judge Karmeier wrote.

“It is our obligation, however, just as it is theirs, to ensure that the law is followed. That is true at all times. It is especially important in times of crisis when, as this case demonstrates, even clear principles and long-standing precedent are threatened. Crisis is not an excuse to abandon the rule of law. It is a summons to defend it,” he wrote.

Judge Karmeir said that if the state could steal our pensions because of a situation the state leaders themselves created, then nobody’s rights or properties were safe.

It is important to remember the role of the state’s union leadership prior to legislature passing pension theft.

There were two bills being considered at the time: Speaker Madigan’s pension theft and State Senate leader John Cullerton’s pension theft.  Both are Democrats.

The We Are One Coalition of state public employee unions supported Cullerton’s bill on the basis that Madigan’s bill was worse. They did not believe that the Court would rule in our favor.

In fact, leaders of the Illinois Education Association like former IEA president Bob Haisman attacked as naive and anti-union those of us who refused to go along with the deal that they cut with Cullerton.

It was only the threat by the Illinois Retired Teachers Association, a relatively small organization of retired educators, to go to court over any diminishment of benefits, that put a wrench into the plan.

Our little band of retirees, activists and bloggers also opposed the betrayal by our union leadership.

I bring this up today not to say we told you so. I bring it up because the threats to the pensions of public employee’s remain and the leadership of the state’s public employee union’s willingness to compromise over principle in exchange for a seat at the table has not appeared to have changed either.

One of my fellow retirees and blogger wrote about the IEA’s betrayal at the time.

Call me “naïve” or an “idealist” for believing public employees and retirees have pension benefits that must be protected against being “diminished or impaired,” that an employee’s and retirees’ rights to a constitutionally-guarantee compensation and the legislators’ obligation to safeguard that promise should be found irrefutable in state and federal courts of law.

Because the foundation of citizens’ rights is the State and U.S. Constitutions, I believe that state contracts are protected; that the fifth and fourteenth amendments of the United States Constitution protect due process of law, and that Article XIII, Section 5 of the Constitution of the State of Illinois also protects public employees’ and retirees’ pensions.  I believe the legal basis for protection of past-and-future public pension benefits and rights are established in both constitutions unless, of course, they are foolishly traded away through consideration or modification of contract principles.

I wrote many times in this blog that a constitutional contract between the State of Illinois and its public employees must be viewed as a legal, moral commitment and requirement of justice, that justice demands we keep our covenants with one another, and keeping an agreement means a concern to promote the well-being of public employees and retirees and to secure their rights and benefits without any devaluation of the agreement.

New IEA officers were elected at last month’s state convention. Will they reject the past practice of supporting pension theft in exchange for a seat at the table?


This week’s episode of Hitting Left with the Klonsky Brothers is in podcast form ready for download. 


4 Replies to “May 8th is Illinois Constitution Day.”

  1. In response to your last question the answer is not only no, it is hell no. Tully was a NEA, “yes man” director who helped give us the Hilary early endorsement for the same reason. Tom and I spoke in person in Normal right after the ridiculous early endorsement and he was pushing the company line hard. I believe the IEA is in for hard times in the next few years with our new leadership, or lack there of.

  2. Back to House & Currie’s (& Durkin’s)Pension Bills–they are hearing them today (4 PM) in committee–4027 & 4505–the first 2 bills being heard–go to & fill out a Witness Slip (as OPPONENT) for each.

  3. Private health insurance companies, “pre-existing conditions,” private equity, hedge funds, horribly skewed tax laws, etc. etc. & ad nauseam! Dishonesty, grand larceny, and corruption on a scale that defies description… And our beloved U.S. of A. is only Nr. 17 on the corruption scale of 190 or so countries on the face of Planet Earth? Only Nr. 17 even with that orange-haired grifter and possible successor to Benedict Arnold in the White House??? One would have thought Nr. 1! Sodom and Gomorrah never looked so good!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s