A constitutional change to the pension benefit system? Pritzker says it ain’t gonna happen.

ct-rauner-pritzker-pic-20161213-001-1

From this morning’s Politico Illinois Playbook.

During a Q&A, Ventas CEO Debra Cafaro asked: If people are willing to have “shared sacrifice” and support the graduated income tax, then “why not ask for shared sacrifice across the board and limit the growth of the public employee pension plans?”

The question drew big applause from the business folks who are sensitive to bearing the brunt of taxes when it comes to solving the state’s financial problems. But Pritzker said it’s wrongto connect the two proposals. A constitutional amendment for a graduated income tax is already headed for the 2020 ballot for voters to consider.

And though some might support a separate constitutional change to the pension benefit system, Pritzker says it ain’t gonna happen. The idea already failed in the state Supreme Court in 2013, and lawmakers don’t have the stomach to support it again, he said.

Even if they did, a constitutional pension fix would need voter approval and then, Pritzker added, it would likely be shot down by the U.S. Constitution’s contracts clause.

There are “a lot of other ways” to address the state’s pension problems, he said, pointing to the just-passed pension consolidation bill for police and fire funds and a pension buy-out program.

JB is right on most of this and misses the mark on a few things.

But who’s counting?

It’s been a while since we’ve had a governor who mainly gets it right on public employee pensions.

Certainly not Bruce Rauner.

Certainly not Pat Quinn.

I’ve written often about how a change to the pension protection clause of the Illinois constitution would be meaningless. It could not be applied retroactively to those already in the retirement pension systems. It is unnecessary to change the pensions of future hires.

They have already done that with Tier II and that is a disaster ready to explode.

So, good for JB for recognizing reality. Now go to work on raising the revenue to pay for the needs of the state, including pension obligations.

2 thoughts on “A constitutional change to the pension benefit system? Pritzker says it ain’t gonna happen.

  1. Teachers in Indiana are finally showing our GOP controlled legislators and GOP governor that they are fed up. Here are photos from the protest in Indianapolis on Nov. 19th. I also sent this message to my state senator and representative:

    Dear Senator Niemeyer [R-IN] and Representative Chyung [D-IN],
    Just wanted to let you know that The Republic, a national news magazine, had a photographer at the teacher protest. The nation is watching and supporting teachers!!!

    Notice the one sign that says, “Our kids are more than a test score”. Exactly!! Standardized tests will NEVER capture what a student is like, nor what a teachers is doing to teach that child. Stop the nonsense and start paying teachers a decent salary.

    Other Signs:
    Teachers can’t afford new glasses but they can clearly see Indiana’s Education Problems!
    TODAY IS A WARNING This is how close we are to striking
    KEEP GREAT TEACHERS IN INDIANA
    The Future is our Classrooms
    INDIANA SCHOOLS DESERVE BETTER
    WHERE IS GOVERNOR HOLCOMB? STOP DEMEANING PUBLIC EDUCATION
    The 90’S called, They want their WAGES back REDforED
    I can’t stay for the entire day. I have to go to my Second Job!
    IF OUR BASKETBALL TEAMS WERE RATED 51st IT WOULD BE A PROBLEM
    LEGISLATORS DO YOUR HOMEWORK
    WE ARE SKIPPING OUR LESSONS TO TEACH YOU ONE

    Sincerely,
    Carol Ring [a retired teacher]

    http://www.therepublic.com/2019/11/19/images-from-todays-red-for-ed-action-day-at-the-indiana-statehouse/#.XdUnahQSTek.gmail

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s