Paul Krugman’s post 9/11 memory and mine.

Paul Krugman’s Tweet today on 9/11.

New York Times columnist Paul Krugman has a very different memory of post 9/11 than I do.

We took no bargain trips to the Virgin Islands.

Instead I remember standing with friends and relatives in front of the Islamic Community Center on the northwest side of Chicago to defend our Muslim neighbors from those who had made threats against them.

Anti-Muslim hatred was real then and continues to this day, fueled now with encouragement from Donald Trump.

Has Krugman lost his mind, his memory or does he just live in a bubble?

By misrepresenting the truth about 9/11 to justify a war framed as one against “Islamic terrorism,” how exactly did Bush calm prejudice?

I was teaching back then. They had just installed a climbing wall in the school’s gymnasium. I was asked to have some students paint a mural around the wall where it was being installed.

For a week after school I gathered buckets of paint and a dozen students. After talking about what would look best, we decided to paint clouds and stars.

Climbing the wall would take P.E. students to the sky!

The Physical Education teacher thought it would be a good idea to add a plane.

So we did.

The gymnasium also served as the lunch room and some lunch parents went nuts when they saw the plane. It was almost as it in their minds they imagined Osama bin Laden in the cockpit.

It seemed that everything we did was framed by fear of Islam and Muslims.

It was suggested I paint it over.

That wasn’t going to happen. I suggested to the principal that there was nothing wrong about painting an airplane in the sky of a mural for a climbing wall.

I even threatened to call a press conference in front of the school if it were painted over. The plane remained.

The good news was that it forced me to think about my Art curriculum and the fact that I had not included anything about Islamic art at any grade level.

So, that year I created a project that included interpreting the aniconic tradition of Islamic design.

Fourth grade was where I taught about architecture and the built environment. It was a perfect time and place to introduce the art of Islam.

I prepared tons of material about Muslim mosques.

I explained what aniconism means. No representations of the male or female form. The practice came from the Islamic prohibition of idolatry and in part from the belief that creation of living forms is God’s prerogative.

With protractor and colored pencils the students designed their interpretations of Islamic tiles.

The results were beautiful and I lined the hallway of our building with them.

It raised a few eyebrows.

I received phone calls.

No press conference was necessary.

5 thoughts on “Paul Krugman’s post 9/11 memory and mine.

  1. 👌✌ Krugman’s in his own bubble

    *Thom Clark 312-405-2142 @thomnewstips www.* *Grandpa, radio host, editor, photographer, educator, activist & chef.*

  2. I was working teaching elementary music and beginning band at the International School of Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia on 9/11. I did exercises in my apartment every morning before going to work. I had CNN International on and saw a plane going into the World Trade Center. I was shocked. I called a good friend in Illinois and asked, “What is happening?” There is a 10-11 hour time difference and this happened when I was asleep.
    The principal called the staff in for a meeting right before school started. We discussed what had happened and how to approach this happening in case any child had questions.
    Later, all communication with the States had been cut off. I really felt stranded until once again I could call people back in the States.
    I am horrified by the things Trump has done to show his hatred for Muslims. One of my best Malaysian friends is a Muslim and we correspond mostly by email now. She has said that she would never come to the U.S. while Trump is president. Several other of my foreign friends have commented about how awful he is. It is sickening to know that at this time he still might be re-elected.

  3. Great story, Fred. Have been reading your stuff for a while, reposting this and others on FB. And forwarding your posts about teachers’ pensions to my teacher friends.

  4. Fred, your response re airplane in mural reminds me what I love about creativity and socially responsible curriculum. I would appreciate photos of the Islamic art/architecture/cultural study you and your students did, just for me. Best, Barbara PS Still teaching college students becoming teachers, part time.

    Dr. Barbara Randolph Columbia College Chicago ________________________________

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s