Teacher layoffs every year makes no sense.

The news that CPS was laying off 443 teachers this week hit me in the gut as it always does.

As a young teacher I was a victim of Reduction in Force every year for the first four years of my teaching career.

Nobody said I was a bad teacher. They just said I was fired.

For a young teacher the first years are brutal anyway. This pandemic year? I can’t even imagine.

And then be hit with a RIF (Reduction in Force) Notice.

Widget. Cog in a wheel. Thing. Nobody. 

CPS says that they have no choice since they don’t know what the enrollment will look like in the Fall.

But they also say that they will likely add 2,000 positions when schools open.

This is likely true. 

So the layoffs make no sense.

It is also likely that the teachers who are let go have no guarantees that they will be among the 2,000 who are rehired. And I can tell you that being told you will likely be called back doesn’t make the feeling of being fired less painful.

It was painful even the fourth time they let me go. Only to call me back again in August.

What kind of system treats its employees this way? Who fires people every year knowing they will likely ask them to return. And then fires them again. Brings them back. And fires them again.

The teachers union leaders complain each year but they never seem to want to challenge the basic assumption. They’d rather try to make points in their continuing battle with the Mayor.

Everything I read says there is a teacher shortage. Enrollment in college teacher prep programs is down 22%. Senior teachers are retiring and there’s fewer new teachers in the pipeline to replace them.

Where is the incentive to enter the teaching profession? It’s certainly isn’t the salary or the Tier 2 pension reductions or a sense of stability or empowerment.

The assumption that needs to be challenged by our union leaders is why are we laying off any teachers at all? 

I say keep them all and find a place for them to do what they are trained to do: teach!

What’s the worst that could happen? 

A group of kids would have two professionally trained educators in a classroom available to them instead of one?


6 thoughts on “Teacher layoffs every year makes no sense.

  1. Seems like something the union should fight for. Is the problem that CPS leaves rehiring up to principals, so the teachers have to reapply for a position? Seems like a way principals (and CPS) can get rid of teachers they don’t like. Seniority then is very restricted.

    1. Paul. There are specific problems with the way the CTU has bargained and enforced contractual layoffs. But they are not unique. 600 districts in Illinois and almost all RIF young teachers every year. The CTU is wrong calling them cuts. They are a yearly standard operating procedure and it is shameful that both AFT and NEA and their affiliates accept it.

  2. It makes it impossible to plan for your class, too, since you never know who or what you will be teaching. Stupid.

  3. RIF’s are a great way to ensure a compliant workforce. : – (

    Not so great for those who have been RIF’d.

    It’s hell to get RIF’d, especially if you have a medical condition and you have to live with the uncertainty of losing your health insurance, especially in our greed-based system.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s